Operations Buzz

5 Products, 5 Supply Chains, 5 Carbon Footprints

April 11th, 2010

by

Individuals, corporations, even governments have adopted carbon emissions as an indicator of our impact on the environment.  As part of the Earth Day 2010 series of articles, this article will explore the “carbon footprints” of 5 common products: Tropicana Orange juice,  a Big Mac, iPhone 3GS, Patagonia Nano Puff Jacket, and Nika Bottled water.

A carbon footprint of a product measures the total amount of carbon dioxide (CO2) that it produces from “cradle to grave.” This typically includes the amount of CO2 produced in the extended supply chain: from the extraction of raw material, to the manufacture, transport, and use of the product; ending  eventually in the disposal and recovery of the product. Of course, other greenhouse gases (such as Methane) are produced but are converted to its “CO2 equivalent” weight so a single CO2 number can  represent the environmental impact of the product. Read, share, and enjoy (and yes, next time you buy something, take a look at its carbon footprint).

Calculating the carbon footprint  and interpreting it is difficult  for many reasons. First, there are no established standards for footprint calculations.  Even those that exist, like the UK’s PAS 2050 and the  EPA’s guidelines for Green House Gas (GHG) inventory in the USA, have yet to be widely adopted, making it difficult for the average consumer to compare footprints of competing products. Second, there is little agreement on what or how much to include in a footprint. For example, If you’re looking to calculate the carbon footprint of bottled water, do you consider only the emissions directly created in its production, transportation, and disposal? Or do you include the greenhouse gas emissions created during the mining of metals, which are used to make the machinery, which are then used to create bottles, purify water, and package it for sale?

It is also unclear how a customer should use the footprint. Take for example the “paper or plastic” question millions of shoppers get asked everyday. Would it surprise you that paper bags have a much higher footprint than plastic ones ? According to the National Resource Defense Council, paper bags use up 14 million trees per year while 12 million barrels of oil are used to make plastic bags. Manufacture of paper bags pollute the air more but plastic leaves four times as much solid waste.  Does this mean we choose plastic over paper? Of course not. Ironically, footprint calculations have pointed us in a new popular direction – “reusable bags” – to reduce our impact on the environment.

Finally, footprints  do not resolve how policy makers can regulate for a better environment. It turns out that in many industries such as electronics and automobiles, the biggest part of the footprint comes from the use of the product. For example, half of Apple’s MacBook Pro’s (this article was typed on one) comes from customer use. So, should there be incentives for me to use my computer less? Or for Apple to design a more energy efficient computer?

These are tricky questions, and each firm approaches the problem in a unique fashion. Some address the issues more thoroughly than others, as you will discover. A good carbon footprint will provide a map of the supply chain that will lead the way to identifying areas for improvement and suggesting ways to reengineer the process in order to reduce carbon emissions;  and the resulting impact on the environment.

For better or worse, carbon emissions is now the de facto surrogate for environmental impact. The  caveat is that the “carbon footprint” is only one of many indicators that businesses, customers, and policy makers should use to improve processes, lifestyles, or regulations to reduce man-made impact on the planet. Following are 5 common products, their supply chains, and the CO2 footprint. All are self-reported. Follow the links, decide for yourself how much impact these products have.

Tropicana Orange Juice

Tropicana ’s footprinting exercise showed that cultivation of orange trees and the energy required to squeeze, pasteurize, and pack the juice makes up about 60% of the footprint.   The biggest challenge in the production stage comes  from fertilizer production and application, which accounts for more than half  the energy required to grow trees and  squeeze juice from the fruit. Turns out that a great deal of nitrogen fertilizer is applied to orange trees to boost their yield; and a lot of energy is used up making nitrogen fertilizers. Pepsi Co which makes Tropicana, is working with its suppliers to reduce the carbon emissions during this stage.

Once packaged (about 15% of the footprint), the cartons are shipped by train throughout the country. Though train-travel is more efficient than shipping by truck, 22% of the CO2 emissions are produced during the distribution phase.

All told, one half gallon of Tropicana not-from-concentrate orange juice is estimated to result in the emission of approximately 3.75 pounds of carbon dioxide equivalent.

Carbon Footprint for 1/2 gallon Tropicana Pure Premium

A Cheeseburger

But if you thought your daily glass of orange juice at breakfast was somewhat of an environmental concern, imagine this: that cheeseburger you had for lunch has a footprint of about 13.4 pounds.

So why 13.4 pounds? Because there are many, many moving parts in the production of a single cheeseburger each with their own energy requirements. Here’s a quick breakdown of many of the points of energy consumption from farm to table (3.6 MegaJoules (MJ) = 1 Kilowatt Hour (Kwh). A 1500 square ft. home in the US on average uses about 50 Kilowatt hours per day):

  • Bread – 3.2 megajoules (MJ), including crop production, milling, baking, storage, and transportation.
  • Hamburger – 10 MJ, which includes energy for producing cereals and protein for cattle, building use for stabling, slaughtering, and cutting, electricity for grinding and freezing, as well as energy for transportation and frying.
  • Lettuce – 4.36 MJ for crop production, storage, and transportation.
  • Onions (freeze dried) – 0.12 MJ, including energy used for agriculture, freeze-drying, storage, and transport.
  • Cucumber (pickled) – 0.056 MJ for growing, storing, pickling, and transportation.
  • Cheese – 0.9 MJ for growing crops, producing cattle feed, producing the cheese, then transporting and storing it.

When added together and converted to carbon dioxide equivalents according to one estimate, all of these energy drains combined result in up to 6.8 pounds of greenhouse gas emissions.

But these numbers only take the direct energy inputs into consideration. There’s also the matter of the emission of methane, a greenhouse gas that’s 21+ times more potent in its heat-trapping capability than carbon dioxide. Livestock (cattle in this case) emit huge quantities of methane during their lifetimes through the normal digestion process (that’s  “farting” and “burping”), putting the per-burger impact of this portion of the chain somewhere between 7.9 pounds to 13.4 pounds. That brings the total emissions per burger potentially to 20.2 pounds per sandwich.

We Americans consume approximately 195 million burgers annually. Think about this: that’s equivalent to approximately 19.6 million SUVs-on the road!

Big Mac Carbon Footprint

Patagonia’s Nano Puff Pullover Jacket

My new favourite piece of clothing is Patagonia’s  Nano Puff jacket. Light-weight and warm, I have been using it lately for everything – from rock climbing to taking kids to the park.  Patagonia publishes the “Footprint Chronicles” on their web site, that tells us the carbon footprint for most of their products.

The energy used to create this jacket is rather small. Patagonia estimates that it consumes about 43 MJ, which is equivalent to burning an 18W light bulb for 28 days straight (24 hours per day). The activities in the extended supply chain is included in this number, including pick-up of the original fibers to manufacturing power consumption through its 12,545 mile journey to the Reno, NV distribution center in the US. This translates to a CO2 emissions of 6 pounds. That’s about 11 times the weight of the finished garment. They also calculate manufacturing waste production to be about 3 ounces (about one-third the garment’s finished weight), and since it is fully recyclable when it is no longer wanted, that should be the extent of the waste.

Not included in this footprint is the energy required to keep the jacket clean  (if you are like me thats only a few times a year).

iPhone 3GS

As an energy-using gadget, the iPhone 3GS will produce greenhouse gas emissions over the entire life of the product—from manufacture to daily use to end-use recycling. Apple produces Environmental Reports for its products in which they breakdown all of the energy used and how they are working to minimize the energy costs in order to shrink the iPhone’s carbon footprint.

Apple has categorized the iPhone 3GS’s greenhouse gas emissions as follows:

  • Production – 45%
  • Customer use – 49%
  • Transport – 5%
  • Recycling – 1%

About half  of the 121 pounds of carbon dioxide (equivalent) are attributed to customer use. The consumer influences the final carbon footprint of each individual device.

Apple has implemented several programs to shrink the overall carbon footprint of the iPhone 3GS. The power adapter is ENERGY STAR qualified, raw materials used for production are limited through innovative  design, packaging is minimized and is almost 100% recyclable, and the components and software of the iPhone 3GS are configured to use energy as minimally as possible. The iPhone 3GS’s additional environmental achievements include reduction in toxic materials such as arsenic, brominated flame retardants, mercury, and PVC.

iPhone Footprint

NIKA Bottled Water

NIKA, a bottle water producer, discovered were the following per-bottle CO2e (carbon dioxide equivalent) emissions:

  • Raw materials – 73 grams
  • Materials manufacturing and transport – 43 grams
  • Product manufacturing and transport – 105 grams
  • Consumer use – 2 grams
  • End of life – 3 grams
  • Total – 226 grams (about half of a pound)

Producing the plastic bottles is one of the biggest energy uses of producing bottled water.

NIKA is now working on localizing their bottled water production facilities. By sourcing, purifying, and bottling their water in a handful of geographically differentiated locations throughout North America, they are able to minimize the use of transportation for their product.

Working with Carbonfund.org, NIKA now offsets their product’s carbon footprint by contributing to a reforestation project in Nicaragua. As a result, they have achieved “CarbonFree” certification from Carbonfund.org, allowing them to claim that they are a carbon neutral company—the first of its kind in the bottle water industry in the US.

Recent articles

Share & enjoy

Comments

  1. Los Mandarinos

    April 25th, 2010

    Bookmarked your web site. Thank you for sharing. Definitely worth the time away from my coursework.

Leave a comment


*

  • Lebron soldier 11
  • Puma Fenty
  • lebron soldier 9
  • stephen curry shoes
  • yeezy shoes
  • adidas nmd
  • lebron soldier 10
  • lebron shoes
  • ultra boost adidas
  • lebron soldier
  • curry one
  • kd shoes
  • kyrie irving shoes
  • kyrie 1
  • Curry 1
  • stephen curry jerseys
  • lebron shoes
  • nike vapormax
  • kd shoes
  • Kevin Durant shoes
  • Curry Shoes
  • kyrie 2
  • adidas nmd shoes
  • john wall shoes
  • puma fenty
  • adidas john wall
  • asics shoes
  • j wall shoes
  • curry 3 shoes
  • curry 3
  • http://www.stephencurryshoes.com
  • kd 9
  • Yeezy 550
  • kobe 12
  • Yeezy 550 boost
  • Yeezy 550
  • http://www.kd-9.org
  • yeezy boost 350 v2
  • Yeezy 550 boost
  • lebron james shoes
  • lebron shoes
  • curry shoes
  • lebron 13
  • kd shoes
  • Curry 3
  • Curry 1
  • http://www.curry1.org
  • kevin durant shoes
  • kyrie 1 shoes
  • kyrie irving shoes
  • kyrie shoes
  • yeezy boost
  • adidas nmd Runner
  • adidas nmd r1
  • kobe 10
  • irving shoes
  • adidas crazy explosive
  • kyrie 4
  • crazy explosive
  • crazy explosive shoes
  • NMD Human Race
  • kobe 10 shoes
  • adidas nmd xr1
  • kobe shoes
  • Stephen Curry Shoes
  • curry one
  • curry one
  • hyperdunk 2016
  • nike hyperdunk 2016
  • kobe bryant shoes
  • kobe shoes
  • nike kobe shoes
  • hyperdunk shoes
  • vans shoes
  • Hyperdunk Flyknit Shoes
  • vans outlet
  • stephen curry shoes
  • vans for sale
  • nike hyperdunk
  • Curry 3
  • yeezy 350 boost
  • Baseball Bats
  • kobe bryant shoes
  • lebron soldier shoes
  • lebron soldier
  • lebron soldier
  • lebron soldier
  • Nike hyperdunk
  • lebron 14
  • lebron 14 shoes
  • hyperdunk
  • lebron james 14
  • hyperdunk Shoes
  • kyrie 4 Shoes
  • kyrie 4
  • hyperdunk 2016
  • lebron soldier basketball shoes
  • under armour shoes
  • ua shoes
  • lebron basketball shoes
  • nike lebron soldier
  • nike free tr 6
  • nike free tr
  • adidas tubular instinct
  • adidas tubular instinct boost
  • adidas ultra boost
  • ultra boost Shoes
  • adidas ultra boost Uncaged
  • Ultra Boost
  • adidas tubular
  • nike free
  • Cheap hyperdunk
  • lebron soldier shoes
  • air jordan shoes
  • jordan shoes
  • jordan basketball shoes
  • jordan retro
  • air max shoes
  • nike air max
  • air max nike
  • kyrie shoes
  • nike kyrie shoes
  • kyrie 2
  • lebron soldier shoes
  • soldier shoes
  • air max 90
  • air max 95
  • bape hoodie
  • bape jacket
  • bape hoodie
  • bape clothing
  • bape hoodie jacket
  • bape hoodie shark
  • bape puma
  • bape Pants
  • Asics Gel Kayano
  • kobe 11
  • Curry One
  • stephen curry shoes
  • Nike Huarache
  • Kobe Shoes
  • lebron 13
  • harden shoes
  • Curry One
  • kobe 11 shoes
  • Under Armour Shoes
  • Curry 2
  • Curry 2
  • kyrie 2 shoes
  • D Rose 6
  • harden shoes sale
  • yeezy 350
  • http://www.yeezy350.org
  • Harden 1
  • kyrie 2
  • Curry 2
  • michael jordan shoes
  • jordan shoes
  • Gel Kayano
  • kyrie 2
  • air jordan shoes
  • Rose 6
  • James Harden Shoes
  • Curry Shoes
  • curry one
  • michael jordan
  • Stephen Curry Shoes
  • lebron soldier
  • lebron 10 soldier
  • nike lebron soldier
  • Rose 6
  • Curry Jerseys
  • curry shoes
  • Curry Shoes 2015
  • Stephen Curry Shoes
  • Harden 1 Shoes
  • James Harden Shoes
  • James Harden Shoes For Sale
  • Cheap Baseball Bats
  • Harden Shoes
  • Asics Kayano
  • Curry Shoes MVP
  • Curry Shoes
  • Cheap Curry Shoes
  • Stephen Curry Jersey
  • James Harden 1
  • Baseball Bats For Sale
  • Nike Air Force 1
  • Air Force 1
  • Air Force 1 shoes
  • Under Armour Curry Shoes
  • Air Huarache
  • kobe x
  • Kobe 10
  • Nike Harden Shoes
  • Asics Running Shoes
  • Baseball Bats Outlet
  • Cheap Harden 1
  • Curry Jersey
  • Nike Huarache Shoes
  • kobe bryant shoes
  • kobe shoes
  • Cheap Curry Shoes
  • yeezy 950
  • Baseball Bats Store
  • Curry One Mvp
  • Nike Harden Shoes
  • Cheap Curry Jersey
  • Asics Shoes
  • Air Huarache Shoes
  • Baseball Bat
  • Nike Kobe Shoes
  • Harden Shoes
  • Under Armour Store
  • Baseball Bats Sale
  • Asics Shoes Women
  • Huarache Shoes
  • Curry Jersey Sale
  • Curry basketball Shoes
  • Curry 2 Shoes
  • Stephen Curry Jersey sale
  • Curry Shoes
  • curry 1
  • Stephen Curry Shoes
  • Under Armour curry one
  • James Harden Shoes
  • Stephen Shoes
  • stephen curry shoes
  • New Curry Shoes
  • Steph Curry 1
  • James Harden Shoes 2015
  • Harden Shoes 2015
  • Asics Shoes Men
  • Stephen Curry Shoes
  • Air Huarache Run
  • kobe basketball Shoes
  • Nike Harden Shoes
  • Nike James Harden Shoes
  • kyrie 4
  • Harden Shoes For sale
  • Harden Shoes Sale
  • nike lebron james shoes
  • yeezy boost
  • new balance shoes
  • kanye west shoes
  • http://www.yeezyshoes.us.com
  • kobe x shoes
  • nike kyrie 1
  • kyrie shoes
  • kyrie irving shoes
  • lebron james jerseys
  • lebron jerseys
  • kyrie 1 shoes
  • Huarache Run Women
  • kyrie 1
  • kd 8
  • kobe jersey
  • Cheap kobe jersey
  • adidas rose shoes
  • derrick rose shoes
  • lebron james shoes
  • tissot watches
  • nike kd 8
  • kd 8
  • tissot 1853
  • tissot watches for sale
  • russell westbrook shoes
  • westbrook shoes
  • Huarache Run Men
  • russell shoes
  • Air Huarache Sale
  • jordan westbrook shoes
  • lebron james jersey
  • kyrie irving shoes
  • nike kyrie 1
  • Nike Huarache Sale
  • cheap kyrie 1
  • michael jordan jerseys
  • Nike Hyperdunk
  • Nike Hyperdunk Basketball Shoes
  • Hyperdunk Shoes
  • adidas nmd xr1
  • adidas nmd r1
  • adidas nmd
  • adidas nmd runner
  • adidas nmd pk
  • adidas nmd footlocker
  • Nike Hyperdunk Shoes
  • jordan jerseys
  • michael jerseys
  • kevin durant jersey
  • kd jersey
  • kevin jersey
  • kobe bryant jerseys
  • kobe bryant jersey
  • james jerseys
  • cheap lebron jerseys
  • d rose shoes
  • rose shoes
  • lebron james jerseys
  • lebron jersey
  • james jersey
  • d rose shoes
  • rose shoes
  • adidas rose shoes
  • lebron james shoes
  • tissot 1853
  • kobe bryant shoes
  • kobe shoes
  • lebron soldier ix
  • lebron 15
  • lebron soldier
  • lebron soldier shoes
  • kobe 12 shoes
  • michael jordan jersey
  • nike shoes
  • kd shoes
  • kd shoes
  • Curry 1
  • Curry 1 Shoes
  • Stephen Curry 1
  • kd 7 shoes
  • kd 7
  • lebron shoes
  • cheap lebron james shoes
  • nike lebron shoes
  • lebron shoes
  • kyrie irving shoes
  • kyrie shoes
  • kyrie 1 shoes
  • kyrie 1 shoes
  • irving shoes
  • kyrie 3
  • nike kyrie 3
  • kyrie 3 shoes
  • air max shoes
  • nike air max shoes
  • stuart weitzman boots
  • stuart weitzman shoes
  • stuart weitzman sale
  • stuart weitzman 5050
  • nike air max
  • durant jersey
  • kevin durant shoes
  • kd vii
  • kd 7
  • curry 3
  • curry 3 shoes
  • ua curry 3
  • curry 3 low
  • kobe bryant jersey
  • kobe bryant jerseys
  • kobe jerseys
  • kyrie 3
  • bryant jerseys
  • adidas porsche shoes
  • kyrie 3 shoes
  • adidas porsche design shoes
  • lebron james shoes
  • kobe shoes 2015
  • nike air shoes
  • nike air max shoes
  • kyrie 3
  • kyrie 3 shoes
  • nike kyire 3
  • cheap air max shoes
  • air max shoes
  • kd vii shoes
  • nba jerseys
  • kd shoes
  • kevin durant shoes
  • adidas zx flux
  • adidas zx
  • jordan retro
  • adidas tubular
  • adidas tubular Shadow
  • adidas tubular Radial
  • adidas tubular Viral
  • adidas tubular Defiant
  • adidas flux
  • cheap kd shoes
  • ultra boost
  • adidas ultra boost
  • kobe shoes nba
  • timberland shoes
  • timberland boots
  • timberland
  • timberland outlet
  • palladium boots
  • lebron soldier 10
  • nike air max 2017
  • air max 2017
  • lebron soldier
  • lebron soldier shoes
  • nike lebron soldier
  • air jordan retro/a>
  • cheap kobe shoes
  • soldier 10
  • kd shoes
  • kevin durant shoes
  • kevin durant shoes
  • jordan retro shoes
  • kd 7 shoes
  • kevin durant shoes mvp
  • porsche design shoes
  • adidas porsche design
  • adidas shoes
  • kevin bryant shoes
  • kd shoes store
  • kd 7
  • nba jerseys store
  • herve leger dresses
  • kobe shoes
  • kobe bryant shoes
  • kd shoes
  • kd sneaker
  • ultra boost 3.0
  • adidas alphabounce
  • rose 7
  • d rose 7
  • adidas boost
  • nmd boost
  • yeezy boost
  • Ultra boost
  • ZX Flux boost
  • Stan Smith boost
  • Superstar boost
  • EQT boost
  • adidas d rose 7
  • adidas alphabounce Xeno
  • Puma Rihanna Creepers
  • Rihanna Creepers
  • Puma Rihanna Creepers Suede
  • Puma Rihanna Creepers Camo
  • Puma Rihanna Creepers Velvet
  • Puma Rihanna Fenty Slides
  • Puma Rihanna Creepers Shoes
  • adidas alphabounce Ams
  • adidas alphabounce Shoes
  • jeremy scott adidas
  • jeremy scott wings
  • jeremy scott shoes
  • js wings
  • adidas terrex
  • Adidas Outdoor Terrex
  • Adidas Outdoor Terrex Trailmaker
  • adidas terrex shoes
  • lebron shoes
  • kobe shoes
  • balenciaga shoes
  • kobe bryant shoes
  • Puma Fenty Slides
  • Puma Fenty
  • Puma Fenty by Rihanna
  • Rihanna Sandals
  • Rihanna Slides
  • Puma Disc
  • Puma Disc Blaze
  • Puma Disc Shoes
  • Puma Rihanna
  • Puma Rihanna Fenty
  • asics gel kayano 23
  • canada goose
  • asics gel kayano 22
  • asics gel lyte iii
  • Puma Fenty By Rihanna
  • Puma Fenty Sandals
  • Puma Fenty Fur Slides
  • Nike PG1 Shoes
  • Nike PG1
  • nike sock racer
  • nike air sock racer og
  • Nike PG1 Shining
  • Nike Paul George 1
  • adidas yeezy boost
  • canada goose
  • Nike Pg1 Shine
  • damian lillard shoes
  • d lillard shoes
  • adidas eqt
  • nike sock racer
  • kd 10
  • nike kd 10
  • kyrie 3
  • adidas nmd r2
  • Lebron soldier 11
  • nike air max flair
  • adidas nmd womens
  • air jordan 1
  • keen uneek sandals
  • prada shoes
  • air jordan 31
  • nike air poresto
  • nike air vapormax
  • nike air vapormax flyknit
  • nike huarache
  • calvin klein
  • calvin klein underwear
  • calvin klein outlet
  • yeezy boost
  • reebok pump fury
  • reebok pump superme
  • adidas yeezy boost 350 v2 zebra
  • reebok pump fury
  • reebok pump superme
  • adidas iniki
  • ultra boost 4.0
  • Nike air force 1 flyknit
  • Nike air force 1 Multicolor
  • adidas ultra boost 4.0
  • Nike air force 1 Oreo
  • Nike air force 1 Ultra
  • Nike air force 1 Casual Shoes
  • nike air max 90 ultra
  • nike air max 90
  • nike air max 90 ultra Essentil
  • nike air max 90 ultra Moire
  • nike air max 90 ultra Flyknit
  • nike air max 90 ultra Hyyperfuse
  • wholesale hats
  • wholesale caps
  • oakley holbrook
  • ultra boost 4
  • oakley holbrook sunglasses
  • oakley sunglasses
  • adidas superstar
  • New Era Hats
  • Cheap Snapbacks
  • Snapback Hats
  • nike zoom all out
  • nike zoom all out low
  • nike zoom all out flyknit
  • nike zoom all out shoes
  • curry 4
  • Wholesale Snapback Hats
  • curry 4
  • kd 10
  • nike kd 10
  • kevin durant 10
  • adidas pure boost
  • curry 4
  • birkenstock sandals
  • lebron 15 shoes
  • birkenstock shoes
  • nike flyknit racer
  • nike air force 1 high
  • nike air force ones
  • nike roshe run
  • nike roshe run one
  • nike air more uptempo supreme
  • nike air more uptempo x suprem
  • air more uptempo
  • supreme x nike
  • nike supreme
  • nike roshe run two
  • kyrie 4
  • puma suede
  • nike zoom vaporfly elite
  • nike zoom vaporfly
  • mizuno shoes
  • mizuno running shoes